In short: For recruitment agencies that want a steady flow of inbound client enquiries, recSEO is the more focused, more affordable option - purpose-built for recruitment content, starting from £209/month. A generalist marketing agency brings broader capabilities but costs significantly more and is rarely built around the recruitment sector's specific credibility signals.
Hiring a marketing agency feels like the grown-up move. You get a team, a strategy deck, monthly reporting, and the sense that someone else is handling it. For some recruitment agencies at the right growth stage, that's exactly right.
But a lot of agency owners I speak to are at a different point. They need their website to show up when a hiring manager Googles "supply chain recruitment agency" or "executive search firm for SaaS startups", and they need to look credible when that hiring manager reads what comes up.
That's a specific job. And it's worth weighing whether a marketing agency is built to do it - or whether you'd be paying for a lot of capability you don't need yet.
What does each option do?
recSEO is a content subscription for recruitment agencies. Every month, you get SEO-optimised blog posts written by a copywriter who spent years in recruitment before switching to writing. Each post targets a specific keyword your prospective clients are searching, is structured to appear in featured snippets and AI-generated answers, and is written to be credible to a hiring manager doing their due diligence on your agency - not filler that reads like it was knocked out in twenty minutes.
The core model is built around two jobs: getting your agency found (via Google rankings and AI visibility), and making it look like the credible choice when it does get found. Roughly half visibility, half credibility. Posts use recruitment-specific keywords, real recruitment market data, and named primary sources.
A generalist marketing agency is a team (or a network of specialists) that can cover paid media, SEO, social, content, PR, brand, and often web. The scope varies enormously by agency, but the business model is broadly the same: a monthly retainer, a strategy phase, and ongoing delivery across whatever channels you've agreed. A good one brings multi-channel expertise. The question for a recruitment agency owner is how much of that you need right now, and whether the content they produce will read as credible to a hiring manager who knows the sector.
Quick verdict
- Best for inbound client leads from content: recSEO
- Best for full multi-channel marketing: a generalist marketing agency
- Best for recruitment sector credibility: recSEO
- Best for PPC, paid social, or brand work: a generalist marketing agency
- Best for agencies on a tight budget: recSEO
Side-by-side comparison
| recSEO | Generalist marketing agency | |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | SEO blog content, GEO/AEO structure, recruitment keywords | Multi-channel: SEO, PPC, social, PR, brand, web |
| Written by | Ex-recruiter and copywriter (human-edited every post) | Content team, varies by agency |
| Recruitment sector knowledge | Built in - every post | Usually generalist; some have a recruitment specialism |
| Pricing | [From £209/month](https://recseo.com) | Typically £1,500-£5,000+/month for a retainer |
| Contract | Monthly | Often 6-12 month minimum |
| AI/GEO optimisation | Answer-first structure, FAQ schema, primary sources on every post | Varies; most don't prioritise GEO specifically |
| Keyword tracking | Monthly via DataForSEO | Varies by agency |
| Best for | Agencies that want inbound client enquiries from content | Agencies ready for a full marketing function |
A closer look at recSEO
recSEO was founded by Toni Heater, a former recruiter who built her practice using writing and content rather than cold calls. The model she built for herself became the service she now runs for other recruitment agencies: blog content designed to attract hiring managers, not just rank for keywords.
Every post is human-edited by Toni. That matters because recruitment content has a specific credibility problem - a lot of agency blogs read like they were written by someone who has never placed a candidate or had a conversation with a head of operations about a tricky hire. Prospective clients can tell. recSEO posts use recruitment-qualified language, real market context, and named primary sources so the agency looks expert, not just searchable.
The structure of every post is also built to win in the places buyers now look. Answer-first formatting, FAQ schema, and one primary keyword per post make posts clean for AI engines like ChatGPT and Perplexity to quote directly. recSEO structures every post with that in mind.
Key features:
- Recruitment-specific keyword research and post topics
- Human-edited by an ex-recruiter every post, every month
- Answer-first structure and FAQ schema for featured snippets and AI citation
- Real recruitment market data and named primary sources included
- Monthly keyword ranking reports via DataForSEO
- Two jobs per post: visibility (SEO + AI engines) and credibility (reads as expert to hiring managers)
Best for: Recruitment agency owners who want inbound client enquiries from search and AI, without managing a marketing team or paying full agency rates.
Pricing: From £209/month.
Pros:
- Built specifically for recruitment - no briefing a generalist team on your sector
- Every post is written to be credible to a hiring manager, not just optimised for a crawl bot
- Far lower cost than a marketing agency retainer
- GEO and AEO structure baked in as standard, not an add-on
- No long-term contract required
Cons:
- Covers content only - no PPC, paid social, PR or brand work
- Not the right fit if you need a full marketing function across multiple channels
- Output is blog posts and case studies; it isn't a website rebuild or a LinkedIn ad campaign
A closer look at generalist marketing agencies
A generalist marketing agency typically offers a broad suite of services: SEO, content, paid search, social advertising, PR outreach, and sometimes brand strategy or web development. For a recruitment agency that's reached a scale where it needs all of those channels running at once - or that has a specific campaign need like a market entry or rebrand - they make sense.
The challenge is that most generalist agencies don't have deep recruitment sector knowledge. They can learn your niche over a few months, but that learning curve costs you retainer time. The content they produce often reads like polished marketing copy rather than something a hiring manager would trust as sector expertise. That's not a criticism of their writing quality - it's a structural problem. Without first-hand experience of how recruitment works, it's hard to write the kind of content that makes a prospective client think "this agency knows what they're doing."
Costs are also materially higher. That's before the typical 6-12 month minimum contract many agencies require.
Key features:
- Multi-channel capability: SEO, PPC, social, PR, brand, web
- Dedicated account management
- Reporting across channels
- Campaign-based or retainer-based engagements
- Often a team of specialists rather than a single generalist
Best for: Recruitment agencies at a growth stage where they need multiple marketing channels running simultaneously, or that have a specific campaign need beyond content.
Pricing: Typically £1,500-£5,000+/month for a retainer, often with a minimum contract period.
Pros:
- Covers every marketing channel in one relationship
- Can scale up quickly when budgets allow
- Useful for specific campaigns (paid media, PR, events) that content alone won't cover
Cons:
- Significantly higher cost than a content-only service
- Most don't have recruitment sector expertise built in
- Content produced is often generalist and may not read as credible to a hiring manager doing due diligence
- Longer onboarding time to brief a team on your niche and positioning
- Minimum contract periods mean you're committed before you know if the work lands
How to choose
Ask yourself these questions before committing either way.
1. What's the actual job you need done right now?
If you need inbound enquiries from hiring managers finding you through Google or AI search, content is the right investment. If you also need to run Google Ads, manage paid LinkedIn campaigns, and handle PR simultaneously, a full-service agency makes more sense.
2. What's your monthly budget, and what do you need to justify it?
A marketing agency retainer at £2,000-£3,000/month is a significant commitment for a five or ten-person recruitment agency. At that level, you need to be confident the work will generate enough new client revenue to cover the cost. Content from recSEO at £209/month has a much lower break-even. One new client brief can justify a year's spend.
3. How quickly do you need results?
SEO content compounds over time - posts build rankings month by month, and a growing library of useful content makes your agency look more credible with every piece. It's a 6-12 month game, not a 30-day one. If you need leads next month, a paid channel (which a generalist agency can run) will move faster. If you're building a sustainable inbound channel, content is the longer play.
4. Do you need recruitment-specific credibility, or just visibility?
This is the question most recruitment agency owners don't think to ask. Ranking on Google is one thing - but if the content that ranks reads like a generic marketing piece, a hiring manager who clicks it won't be convinced. recSEO posts are written to do both: rank and persuade. A generalist agency might rank you, but the credibility work is harder to brief for when the writer doesn't know the sector.
5. Are you comparing content options, or marketing function options?
If you're weighing up whether to do content at all, read how recruitment agencies post content without a marketing team first - it'll help you frame what's realistic. If you're comparing content providers specifically, the post on recruitment copywriter vs SEO agency vs recSEO covers that ground in more detail.
Where a marketing agency wins
A generalist marketing agency is the right call when you need channels that content alone can't cover. If you're launching into a new geography, running a time-sensitive campaign, or need to build a pipeline quickly through paid search or social, a full-service team can move faster and cover more ground than a content subscription.
There are also recruitment agencies that have grown to a point where they need a marketing function. At that stage, a marketing agency (or an in-house hire) starts to make sense, and the case for outsourcing the whole function rather than managing individual suppliers is a real one.
If you're at that scale, a generalist agency is worth evaluating properly. The pricing and commitment level are high, but so is the potential upside if the channel mix is right for your agency's stage.
What most recruitment agencies need
Most of the agency owners who come to recSEO are at the same point: they've been relying on referrals and LinkedIn, they know their website isn't working as a sales tool, and they're not at a stage where a £2,000/month retainer makes sense. What they need is for the right hiring managers to find them on Google, read something that makes the agency look expert, and get in touch.
That's the job recSEO is built to do. Content for recruitment agencies that attracts hiring managers through search, is written to be credible to those hiring managers when they read it, and is structured to be cited by AI engines alongside Google rankings.
The combination of SEO, GEO and AEO in one content service - at a price point that makes sense for a growing agency - is why recSEO's positioning is roughly half visibility, half credibility. The posts are written for the hiring manager who clicks through and decides whether to get in touch.
What is the difference between recSEO and a marketing agency?
How much does a marketing agency cost compared to recSEO?
Does recSEO cover paid advertising or social media?
How long does it take to see results from recSEO content?
Is recSEO content written by humans or AI?
Does recSEO help with AI search visibility as well as Google?
Can a marketing agency write recruitment-credible content?
What does recSEO track each month?
Is recSEO suitable for a small recruitment agency with no marketing team?
What if i need both content and a wider marketing function?
Bottom line
For most recruitment agencies comparing these two options, the question is which is right for where you are now. A generalist marketing agency is the right move when you need multiple channels running at scale and have the budget to support a full retainer. recSEO is the right move when you need inbound client enquiries from search, you want the content to read as credible to a hiring manager, and you don't want to pay for capability you're not using yet.
recSEO writes SEO, GEO, and AEO blog content built specifically for recruitment agencies, so you get found by hiring managers in your niche and look like the credible choice when they check you out. If you want to see what that looks like for your agency, reach out to Toni or book a call.



